![]() ![]() On the other hand, the Girl Scout cookie was softer and chewier. However, every cookie but the Girl Scout brand of Samoas/Caramel Delites was crunchy. Taste of the Caramel Delites plus the genericĮvery cookie, knockoff or not, had a strong coconut smell and taste.Īlso, they each had just enough fudge and caramel. So, I guess, that’s just a wee bit more cookie goodness than the others that have a hole in the middle of the cookie. Only the Girl Scout cookie has a filled-in center. However, in just looking at the cookies overall, they appear to be the same size and similar looking all around. Then, I ate my way around the plate, leaving the Girl Scouts Samoas for last. Keep in mind that the Benton’s cookies are nearly twice the size of the Thin Mint lookalikes. However, I’m not including the Oreos knockoffs because, despite being delicious in their own right, they don’t really taste like a Thin Mints Girl Scout cookie. Here is a side by side comparison of the size of the packaging of each kind of these fudge mint cookies, including how many cookies come in a package. Packaging and servings of Thin Mints and copycats However, the generic versions from Walmart and Keebler were mintier and the centers a darker fudge flavor.Īlso, even though the other two cookies looked different, only the Benton’s Mint Striped Fudge Cookies mimicked the taste and mouth-feel of a Thin Mint. Taste of the Thin Mints vs store-bought copycatsĬlearly, I didn’t tell him which was the Thin Mints and which were the knockoffs.īesides, unless you knew to look for differences–and you really needed a magnifying glass to accomplish that–it would be hard to tell. ![]() What cookies did I compare to Thin MintsĮventually, I was able to find three generic Girl Scout cookie versions that I thought would taste like Thin Mints.įor kicks and giggles, I also added in a mint version of generic Oreos.īenton’s Mint Striped Fudge Cookies from Aldi. That included stalking nearby Walmart stores and Shaw’s supermarkets (they’re in the Albertsons Safeway family) for their version of fudge mint cookies that I hear are just as good as Thin Mints along with Aldi’s. So, that must be saying something about how good those minty knockoffs must be.Īnyway, after visiting multiple stores, I was able to find cookies for the Thin Mints portion of the taste test. I’ll be honest: it was much easier to find the generic version of the Samoas or Caramel Delites Girl Scout cookies than it was the Thin Mints knockoff or copycat version. Generic version of Samoas or Caramel Delites vs Thin Mints This article explain how Girl Scout cookie season works. On the other hand, Little Brownie Bakers make the exact same coconut and fudge cookie, but they call them Samoas. They are in Kentucky.ĪBC Bakers are the ones who make Caramel Delites. The other is called Little Brownie Bakers. Well, it has to do with the bakery that’s contracted to make cookies for different Girl Scout councils. On the other hand, when my daughters were Girl Scouts in Eastern Pennsylvania and I bought my favorite cookie, they were called Caramel Delites. Why Girl Scout cookies have different namesīefore I get into the actual taste test part of this article, I wanted to explain why my favorite Girl Scout cookies, which I bought in Western Pennsylvania, are called Samoas. So, I wanted to offer a taste-comparable and money-saving way to feed that craving. However, there may be times during the year when you’re craving your favorite cookie and Girl Scout sales are not happening. I get that since not only was I a Girl Scout but also I was a troop leader. Look, I know that Girl Scout cookie sales are a fundraiser to help support the Girl Scouts. So, in addition to tasting these cookies side by side, we also did a price comparison. ![]() His favorite is Thin Mints mine is the aforementioned Caramel DeLites aka Samoas. So, we went about finding the generic, store-bought version of our two favorite Girl Scout cookies.Īnd when I say, “we” and “our,” I’m talking about my husband and me. However, other flavors are harder to match. There are lots of Girl Scout cookies where it’s easy to do a taste test comparison with store bought cookies.įor example, I’m guessing you could easily replicate the flavor of Do-Si-Dos or the Girl Scout peanut butter sandwich cookies with nutter butters. Best off season generic Girl Scout cookie.Packaging of Girl Scout cookies vs store bought knockoffs.Taste of the Caramel Delites plus the generic.What cookies did I compare to Caramel Delites.Packaging and servings of Thin Mints and copycats.Taste of the Thin Mints vs store-bought copycats.What cookies did I compare to Thin Mints.Generic version of Samoas or Caramel Delites vs Thin Mints.Why Girl Scout cookies have different names. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |